How do I get a prospect to respond to a cold email?


5 min read

cold email tips to generate response

Table of Contents

What is one thing every cold email must include to generate a response?

To help entrepreneurs and marketers send out the best cold emails possible, we asked marketing experts this question for their best advice. From including “per your request” to using a customer’s name, there are several spectacularly easy tips that may help you send out the best cold emails and generate responses.

Here are 12 cold email tips to generate responses:

  • Include “Per Your Request”
  • Keep It Brief
  • Establish A Human Connection
  • Make Sure the Signature is Good
  • Provide A Clear Call to Action
  • Personalize The Messaging
  • Include A Question
  • Schedule a Call Or Meeting
  • Have a Clear Value Proposal
  • Include Bullet Points
  • Validate Yourself For Credibility
  • Include The Customer Names

Include “Per Your Request”

People are busy. Human nature is such that people are skeptical. Therefore, cold emails may be met with skepticism that you are sending spam pitches. Therefore, you need a subject line that will convince people to open your emails. “Per your request” tells people they want what you are pitching. However, you need to convince people you are a real person and not an AI bot. Explain to them in the email what it is that they requested that your product or service will help them with.

Janice Wald, Mostly Blogging

Keep It Brief

Include detailed information about your amazing company, and keep your email short. Everyone is in a hurry these days, and people’s attention spans are shorter. As a result, no one wants to read a lengthy email. Focus on what’s most important and keep it brief. If you do this, prospective customers will be able to look forward to your company’s emails and not immediately delete them.

Shaun Price, MitoQ

Establish a Human Connection

When it comes to cold emails, authenticity is the only recipe for success. You only get one shot to create an air of familiarity and without being open, honest, and real in your communication, it can be hard to sell someone on an idea, no matter how great the idea actually is. Rather than turning to marketing jargon, try to find the most genuine way that you can get the point across and establish a human connection.

Harry Morton, Lower Street

Make Sure the Signature is Good

When sending a cold email you have to make sure that your signature at the bottom has all the information a person would need in order to contact you or your company. Adding a signature also makes the email have a bit more flair and professionalism. When I receive emails and the signature looks well formatted and professional, I feel much more comfortable when responding.

Connor MacDonald, The Ridge Wallet

Provide a Clear Call to Action

To increase your response rate from a cold email blast, it’s important to include a clear call to action. What do you want the reader to do? Make it incredibly clear and always speak using an active communication style to move things forward. Don’t bury the important info! This will help you establish better relationships with new or mutual connections. People appreciate clear communicators who make their lives easier.

Lisa Odenweller, Kroma Wellness

Personalize The Messaging

Every cold email should have a personalized message. If the email is not personalized, it will likely be ignored or worse, the recipient may unsubscribe and report your email as spam, diminishing your reputation as a sender.

Matthew Ramirez, Rephrasely

Include A Question

Every cold email should include a question to generate a response. People love to feel smart, so if you can make the person you’re emailing feel like they have something valuable to offer, they’re much more likely to respond. Questions are the perfect way to do this because they show that you’re interested in what the other person has to say. Plus, questions help start a conversation, which is exactly what you want in a cold email.

Claire Westbrook, LSAT Prep Hero

Schedule a Call Or Meeting

Every cold email must include a link to quickly and easily schedule a call or a meeting. Customers don’t want to have a back-and-forth email exchange just to set up a call, so if there’s no link to book directly they might not take action. Make sure that it’s clearly identified. Use text like ‘ready to get started?’, ‘click here to set up a discovery call’. This both prompts the customer to take action and makes it easy for them to do so.

Mark Pierce, Cloud Peak Law Group

Have a Clear Value Proposal

Proposing some value is one thing every cold email must include to generate a response. Also known as pitch, it’s where you tell the message receiver what you want from them. While highlighting the benefits of your product or service, you need to point out what’s currently wrong in their system or products and why they should look for a change. Also, it would help if you did it in a way that’s not pushy or salesy. Tell them how you can help fix the problem when you point it out. Additionally, mentioning some of your customers as social proof is an excellent way to build credibility among the recipient.

John Tian, Mobitrix

Include Bullet Points

Include bullet points. Doing this will make these emails easier to read rather than if there is too much text close together in one big paragraph. This will make your cold emails more scannable, which is very important with online reading.

Drew Sherman, RPM

Validate Yourself For Credibility

In every cold email you send out, be sure to quickly and sufficiently demonstrate your credibility to the recipient. Validating yourself will make it easier for them to trust you. For instance, if you have any proven authority or expertise relevant to the individual you’re cold emailing, be sure to point it out. Mutual connections or being a part of the same groups online or off, are another way of validating yourself to the recipient. You could also determine if you have any unique and specific similarities with the recipient and point them out at the beginning of your email to improve your chances of getting a response.

Doug Pierce, Sigma Computing

Include The Customer Names

Many people write it off as a tactic of the past, but if you know how to create a good cold email, you can secure plenty of conversions, and actually create more personalized connections with your consumer-base.One thing every cold email should include is the consumer’s first name. This may seem like a small detail, but it could mean the difference between someone opening your email or tossing it in their trash folder. Adding the first name of the consumer helps the email feel more personal and direct, and supports each consumer’s individual experience with your brand. You never want your cold emails to read like they were written off of a template. You want your audience to develop a personal relationship with your brand, and more personalized cold emails is a surefire way to do that. Audience’s should feel like they’re getting an email from a close friend or mentor, not a business!

Brett Larkin, Uplifted Yoga

Submit Your Answer

Would you like to submit an alternative answer to the question, How do I get a prospect to respond to a cold email?

Submit your answer here.

Related Questions

Terkel creates community-driven content featuring expert insights. Sign up at to answer questions and get published.