Can you share an example of a time you successfully used a pay-what-you-want pricing model? What were the advantages and disadvantages?

Question

Navigating the innovative landscape of 'Pay-What-You-Want' pricing strategies, this article delves into real-world examples that redefine value exchange across diverse sectors. With insights from industry experts, readers will uncover the nuances of PWYW models that drive success in digital marketing, real estate, indie gaming, and more. Learn how these flexible pricing tactics can enhance customer engagement, build community, and remove financial barriers, as revealed by those who've mastered them.

Austin Benton · Answer

A few years ago, I ran a limited-time "Pay-What-You-Want" (PWYW) campaign for a digital marketing guide I created. It wasn't just some generic PDF - I had packed it with high-value insights, templates, and strategies I'd usually charge for. But instead of setting a fixed price, I let buyers decide how much they wanted to pay.
What happened?
Surprise #1: 40% of People Paid More Than My Usual PriceSome customers felt obligated to pay fairly, especially when I framed it as "supporting independent creators." A few people even paid 2-3 times my original price because they perceived it as valuable.
Surprise #2: Conversion Rate SkyrocketedWithout a price barrier, more people downloaded it, including those who might not have paid otherwise. The reach and word-of-mouth boosted my email list by 5 times in a week.
Surprise #3: Some People Paid $0, but It Still WorkedYes, about 25% of buyers paid nothing, but they still entered my funnel.Some of them later became paying customers for other services.
Would I do it again?
Absolutely - but with smart tweaks:
1. Set a Minimum Price for High-Value Offers - A $0 option is great for lead magnets, but premium products need a floor price.2. Use It for Limited-Time Campaigns - This pricing model works best as a temporary offer to create buzz.3. Pair It With Upsells - The real money came from upselling paid services after people got the freebie.
The takeaway? Pay-What-You-Want works best as a marketing tool, not a long-term pricing strategy. It's not really about making a quick profit - it's more about getting people in the door and building long-term relationships with them.

Savannah De La O · Answer

I tried a pay-what-you-want model for my real estate consultation sessions last summer, and surprisingly, most clients paid above my usual rate because they felt more invested in the process. The flexibility built trust and led to more referrals, though I did have a few people who underpaid, which taught me to set a minimum suggested amount.

Jas Bola · Answer

I'm excited to share how I experimented with PWYW pricing for my indie game last year, where players could pay anything from $0-30, and I surprisingly averaged $8.50 per download versus our usual $4.99 fixed price. While we did see some players pay nothing, the goodwill and word-of-mouth marketing we generated led to 3x more downloads overall, plus many players came back later to pay more after enjoying the game – though I'd definitely recommend having a minimum price floor next time.

Jean Chen · Answer

In our early days at Mondressy, we experimented with a pay-what-you-want model during a charity event, offering a limited selection of accessories. Customers could choose their own prices, with the understanding that a portion of the proceeds would support a local charity. This approach generated a surprising sense of community and goodwill, as customers often paid above market value when they felt personally invested in the cause. The major advantage was the enhanced customer engagement and brand loyalty it fostered. However, one significant challenge was accurately predicting inventory needs, as varying perceived value led to unpredictable sales patterns. Flexibility in stock management became crucial, ensuring we could swiftly adjust to demand without compromising quality or delivery times.

Bennett Barrier · Answer

We ran the promotion for a week, offering customers a free consultation and installation quote for their turf projects, allowing them to pay whatever they felt the service was worth. The goal was to engage with a wider audience, increase brand awareness, and let potential customers decide the value of our expertise.
The advantages were clear: we saw a significant boost in interest and engagement, with many customers sharing the offer on social media. It helped us connect with a new demographic that might not have considered artificial turf otherwise. Also, some customers paid above what we might have charged normally, showing trust in our work and commitment to quality.
However, the disadvantages became apparent once we looked at the numbers. While we received some generous payments, a few customers paid far below the actual cost of the services. This left us questioning how sustainable the model was in the long term, especially when considering overhead costs. On top of that, we found that some customers who might have valued the service less didn't perceive the same level of quality as those who paid full price.
In the end, we used this as a way to build rapport with customers, but I wouldn't rely on this model long-term. It's effective for specific promotions or to generate buzz, but consistency in pricing is important to ensure sustainability.

Steve Nixon · Answer

I tried a pay-what-you-want model for some lessons on FreeJazzLessons.com as a way to make content more accessible and see how students would value it. I set a minimum price so it wasn't completely free, but left the rest up to the students. It was great to see how many people took advantage of it, and it definitely created a sense of community. Students seemed more engaged and many shared their experience, which helped spread the word. It felt like everyone had a stake in the platform, and the flexibility made it less intimidating to try.
The downside, though, was that not all the payments were enough to cover the costs of running the platform. While it worked well for bringing in new students and generating buzz, it wasn't a sustainable long-term strategy. Some students paid the minimum, which made it tough to maintain the business on that alone. It's a great way to build excitement and get people in the door, but I quickly realized that it's best used for limited-time promotions, not as the main pricing structure.

Vivian Chen · Answer

I ran a pay-what-you-want model for resume reviews because we knew that many job seekers might not be in a position to pay, but we still wanted to make the service accessible. The results were interesting—some people paid more than expected because they valued the help, while others contributed what they could.
One major advantage? It created commitment. Before, we struggled with no-shows, but once people had to put something down, they were far more likely to show up and engage. The downside? It's unpredictable revenue-wise, but as a way to balance accessibility with accountability, it worked really well.

Patrick Carver · Answer

I experimented with PWYW for initial consultations at my law firm, where clients could decide what the first session was worth to them. This approach helped remove the barrier of high legal fees for many potential clients, and interestingly, most paid close to our standard rate while we saw a 60% increase in people booking initial consultations.

8 Pay-What-You-Want Pricing Examples

Table of Contents

8 Pay-What-You-Want Pricing Examples

Digital Marketing Guide Campaign Surpasses Expectations

Real Estate Consultations Earn Trust and Referrals

Indie Game PWYW Pricing Boosts Revenue

Charity Event Enhances Customer Engagement

Turf Project Consultations Increase Brand Awareness

Music Lessons Model Builds Community

Resume Reviews Create Commitment

Law Firm Consultations Remove Fee Barriers

Up Next